
The unbeaten: Frankel
FRANKEL (1-3) spearheads the QEII Stakes at Newmarket on Saturday October 15 as he bids to land a ninth-straight victory and fifth Group One of a short career which has enthralled the racing world, writes Joel Sheldon. This is muted as being his final tilt at the eight-furlong distance, one that he has utterly dominated this year, as trainer Sir Henry Cecil looks to step him up in trip next season.
Frankel is a phenomenon but still I hear whispers from the shadows, mostly on message boards and forums of people uttering that Frankel has not been fully tested in the races he has contested. Even Tom Segal, Racing Post’s most celebrated tipster, labelled Frankel’s campaign ‘boring’ - suggesting the horse had been given an easy season in his ‘comfort zone’. I take serious issue with these defaming whispers. Just because Frankel has made these victories LOOK easy, it doesn’t mean they were by any means of that simplicity.
So, I’ve taken a look at Frankel’s form book. From that I’ll take the most impressive of those defeated horses, i.e. those that have gone on to win Group One’s or those that had won a Group One either this season or last, therefore I feel I am taking into account any pretender that may have been on the decline when Frankel was victorious.
So below is a list of horses Frankel has defeated, that have won at group level;
Nathaniel (Group 2 & Group1 winner)
Genius Beast (Group 3 winner)
Klammer (Group 3 winner)
Treasure Beach (Group 1, Graded 1 (USA) & Group 3 winner)
Roderic O’Connor (2x Group 1 winner)
New Greenfield (Group 3 winner)
Dream Ahead (6 wins from 9 races. 5 Group 1’s over 6 & 7 furlongs)
Saamidd (Group 2 winner)
Excelebration (5 wins from 8 races, twice beaten by Frankel. Winner of one Group 1 and 2 Group 2’s between 7f & 1m)
Strong Suit (2x Group 2 & 1x Group 3 winner)
Dubawi Gold (2x Listed winner & 1 Group 2)
Native Khan (2 Group 3’s)
Pathfork (Unbeaten until he faced Frankel, Group 1&2 winner)
Rerouted (Group 3 winner)
Casamento (1 Group 1,2&3)
Zoffany (Group 1 & Group 3 winner)
Wooton Bassett (Group 1 winner & unbeaten as a 2yo)
Canford Cliffs (Won 7/11 of his races. 5 Group 1’s in a row & 1 Group 2)
Below is a table showing how many group races the horses Frankel has beaten have either won or gone on to win at Group level, both at home and abroad.
| |
Total Winners |
| Group/Grade 1’s |
20 |
| Group 2’s |
13 |
| Group 3’s |
11 |
Winning Distances
Of the entire Group standard horses above that have been beaten by the mighty Frankel just two, Zoffany and Nathaniel, have managed to get to within a length. The latter pushed him all the way in their maiden at Newmarket last year when the sons of Galileo traded blows right to the line, with the rest of the field floundering five lengths behind.
Zoffany was the next to push Frankel to the limit when getting to within three-quarters of a Length in the St James’s Palace Stakes at Royal Ascot this year. However, it is widely regarded that the man who has been ever-present in the saddle, Tom Queally, gave him an uncharacteristically poor ride. Asked for an effort before the bend on the mile course at Ascot, perhaps taking into account the relatively short straight at the racecourse, Frankel appeared to tire inside the furlong and had almost come to a stand-still in the last 150 yards.
Cecil claimed after the race that it was always the plan to go to the front early. It is my thought that they really wanted to test Frankel, and to see not only if they could settle him in behind the pace, but also how long he could keep up the devastating stride he uses to put his races to bed. I think we can safely say it didn’t go exactly as planned and his handler said: “I don’t think we’ll be riding him like that again”. Queally felt Frankel still had more to give at the line but was simply in front for too long and began to idle given the lack of company for the final two or three furlongs.
Form Lines
From the above list I’m going to take a look at the form lines through the six most impressive horses in their own right. Canford Cliffs, Strong Suit, Excelebration, Nathaniel, Dream Ahead and Treasure Beach, who in my opinion is a top class horse who was ludicrously used as a pacemaker in this year’s Arc De Triomphe at Longchamp.
Nathaniel – Workforce- St Nicholas Abbey
Dream Ahead – Goldikova –Bated Breath-Worthadd-Tin Horse-Strong Suit
Canford Cliffs-Goldikova-Worthadd-Rip Van Winkle-Dick Turpin-Free Judgement-Cape Blanco-Ransom Note-Twice Over
Strong Suit-Red Jazz-Beacon Lodge-Chachamaidee-Western Aristocrat
Treasure Beach-Banned-Seville-Nathaniel-Carlton House-Within a head of Derby winner Pour Moi.
Excelebration-Dubawi Gold-Rajsaman-Rio De La Plata-Royal Bench-Planteur
As you can see the various form lines that I’ve selected are extremely strong and although Strong Suit is yet to add a Group One to his name, his two victories at Group Two level have been executed on the bridle in very taking fashion. Excelebration won the German Guineas by an impressive seven lengths before going on to bigger and better things in France when taking a Group One convincingly against proven types on very testing ground.
Treasure Beach and Nathaniel have proven themselves to be more effective over longer distances since their encounters with Frankel. But, both are still undeniably top class performers with Treasure Beach invading the USA and coming back with the Grade One Secretariat Stakes. Nathaniel meanwhile took the Group Two Edward VII stakes comfortably before returning to Ascot to land the King George eye-catchingly, in what proved a messy race.
The most impressive form line though belongs without doubt to the recently retired Canford Cliffs. He had wins to his name against some greats which included Goldikova and Rip Van Winkle, as well as numerous Group On winner Twice Over, and recent Group Two victor Ransom Note. Also taking into account Cape Blanco’s incredible form in the US - Canford Cliffs was clearly a fantastic miler. Further evidence of Frankel’s domination in this sphere came at Glorious Goodwood when he eased to a five-length success over the Richard Hannon inmate.
For me, this list of very good horses that have consistently finished in behind Frankel makes him the finest Miler around at the moment. I am not here to compare him with past greats; I believe he’ll do that much more efficiently than I can when he steps up in trip next year. All I know, is that it’s going to take something very special to beat Frankel.
But I do believe question marks over his form and whether he is a great horse should be put to rest. His form hasn’t just been franked, it’s been Frankeled.
Click here to visit The Tiki Taka and read more from the Racing Post’s very own Joel Sheldon.